The news that renowned management consultancy McKinsey is to start counselling its clients on social media should send a shiver down the spines of public relations and corporate communications consultancies.
McKinsey has partnered with Nielsen BuzzMetrics to form NM Incite, a social media consultancy. The new company claims it will “help businesses harness the full potential of social media intelligence and focus on measuring the impact social media has on businesses.” NM Incite currently only operates in the USA, but Nielsen has said it is looking to expand into other markets.
Simon Collister is sceptical that a management consultancy can offer genuine communication consultancy and cites the example of “chatting with a senior PR consultant who was lamenting a ‘brand strategy’ put together by the client’s management consultancy.”
Drew Benvie is far more positive, but points out that the services on offer from McKinsey’s new division are all pretty old bread and butter stuff for digital veterans.
I view it as both an opportunity and a threat. The opportunity is that it’s yet more evidence about the strategic importance of social media and its impact on businesses and organisations. The threat is that the management consultants will take more and more business from traditional PR consultancies.
PR still suffers from a reputation of being a ‘fluffy’ management discipline and unfortunately it’s too often justified. At Wolfstar we’ve spent considerable time over the last few months in investing in creating a new communications audit consultancy tool that has an extremely rigorous process and quality control behind it. It’s exactly the sort of tool that many management consultancies offer to clients. We’ve recognised that public relations professionals have got to up their game if they are to compete in the modern world.
[...] the original post here: Can PR survive competition from management consultancies? | A PR … Comments [...]
Interesting post, Stuart – thanks for sharing it.
I get the impression management consultants are desperate to re-frame their offering. Management consultants want to be known as providers of anything but management consultancy.
[...] Can PR survive competition from management consultancies? | A PR Guy's Musings: Stuart Bruce "Help businesses harness the full potential of social media intelligence and focus on measuring the impact social media has on businesses". I seem to have heard this many, many, many, many times. The simple truth is that a combination of content creativity, PR insight, solid strategy and an understanding of how businesses work is rare. I don't see how a combination of a measurement and consultancy company can provide this. Measurement companies lack the strategic insight and execution; consultancies lack the creativity. What I think is right about this partnership is that, as Stuart says, they'll be able to take on the 'fluffy' PR people. What's wrong is that they won't understand communication. Statistics is not communication, and consultancy is not creativity. Nonetheless I await the outcome with interest. (tags: stuartbruce mckinsey nielsen socialmedia) [...]
It's not unknown for management consultancies to dabble in PR. Way back in the day, well the mid 90s, PA Consulting handled the PR for HP in the UK.
[...] Can PR survive competition from management consultancies? (stuartbruce.biz) [...]
[...] been integrating social media into their campaigns and as my manager Stuart Bruce pointed out in his recent blog post, even management companies like McKinsey have started advising on social media. The space for [...]